KitchenAid Stand Mixer vs. Bread Machine Which One Should I Buy

Bread can be used in a lot of delicious recipes and many people, therefore, keep a stock. Buying bread from the store can be rather convenient. If you are someone who buys bread every day then there is one thing you need to know.

The prices of bread are increasing rapidly and especially if you are someone who buys artisan or some more healthy bread. In this situation, many people switch over to baking bread at home instead of buying it from stores as it can save a lot of money. Now you might be wondering how to bake bread at home. Many machines are available in the market for this and you will have to determine which one will suit your purpose.

You can bake bread at home either by kneading it by hand or you can go with a machine as many people do so, a machine makes things easier and quicker. There are two of the most popular machines for kneading which are the KitchenAid stand mixer and a beard machine. Now if there are two options we need to know which one will suit you the best and for that, we will carry out a comparison guide.

If you want to bake your bread at home then having one of these two machines is very important. Today I am going to discuss the KitchenAid stand mixer and bread machine and look at the differences that they have. If you are confused about which one to buy then this article will be pretty helpful for you.

The type of baking you are going to perform will say which machine you want

Deciding what type of machine you are going to buy for your purpose will depend on the type of baking you are going to do.

If you’re not a major baker and don’t want so many cookies, cakes, and other baked foods, you just want an ingredient throwing machine that allows you to see the brown loaf perfectly grow, then a bread machine is there for you.

But if you want to make different kinds of bread from time to time, but also want to make bread loaves, then a stand mixer is the preferred option. We will look at the pros and cons of each machine and it will help to clear all the things and let you know which one you like the most and which one will serve your purpose.

What does a KitchenAid stand mixer offer for making bread?

If you are thinking of buying a KitchenAid stand mixer then it will be a very fine choice to make. It will help you do most of the stuff like mixing and kneading the bread. This is a very good appliance that is versatile.

You need to place the ingredients for making bread dough in the bowl of the mixer and then add the dough hook to the unit. Now you will have to turn on the mixer and let it knead the bread for the amount of time it will need to knead the bread. It is important to remember that a KitchenAid Stand Mixer comes with a dough hook in the initial order, so you don’t need additional attachments, but kneading time takes just as long as it takes to knead the dough manually.

Once the process of dough making is completed you will have to remove it and then carry it out with the bread-making further.

You can only use this machine for the process of making dough and besides that, it won’t do much in bread making. You can, however, use a KitchenAid stand mixer to make pizza, eggs, meatballs, and cupcakes.

Pros for using KitchenAid stand mixer for making bread

  • A KitchenAid stand mixer is very versatile and it will help you to knead the dough for bread for multiple loaves of bread.
  • Many bread types can be created using a KitchenAid stand mixer. You get a big mixing bowl and you can try many things with your ingredients there.
  • It helps to eliminate the use of your hands and saves them from soreness.
  • The texture of the dough will be similar compared to the kneading done with the use of hands.

Cons of using KitchenAid stand mixer for making bread

  • If the temperature inside the room where you are baking bread is cool then it might be difficult to get it to rise.
  • It can only help you knead the bread and nothing else that means you will have to do everything else for the preparation of bread on your own.
  • Buying the attachments can be expensive
  • While buying a KitchenAid stand mixer you will have to evaluate certain things as some models are not very powerful to make tougher bread types.
  • You will have to be pleasant when the mixer is working as there aren’t any timers in most of the models.

What does a Bread Machine offer for making bread?

You will get an option to buy two types of bread machines. One that can do the mixing and the rising of the bread and the other that can do everything and carries out all the work.

Before carrying out a proper comparison between KitchenAid stand mixer and bread machine we will break the two types of bread machines into respective categories.

If you are thinking of purchasing a bread machine that can carry out the mixing and the rising of the bread then you will just have to take all the ingredients and place them inside the machine so that it can knead the dough for you. The inside part of the machine might get warm during the process so that the read rises. Once the dough is prepared and it is done rising then you will have to pull it out from the machine and then put it down and give it a shape.

After this put it inside the machine again to let it rise some more. Once the dough has risen properly then you will need to bake it on your own.

Pros of using a mixing/rising machine for making bread

  • It will help you to speed up the process of mixing and rising
  • It will also help to raise the dough to the best level
  • It has a timer so you won’t have to monitor the process and you can simply set it and walk away.
  • You can shape the bread so it provides you with a chance to control the quality of the end product.

Cons of using a mixing/rising machine for making bread

  • If you do not want to shape the dough or punch it down on your own then it can be a problem for you.
  • This machine will only help you to prepare the dough.

If you are thinking of purchasing a bread machine that is capable of carrying out all the work then all you are required to do is simply place the ingredients inside the machine and let it mix, knead, bake, and raise your bread. It can do everything. This can be the best option for preparing bread. You can walk away while the machine prepares the bread and when you return you will get freshly baked bread.

Pros of using a full bread machine

  • It has a timer so you don’t have to monitor the whole process. You can set the timer and walk away.
  • You can prepare your bread at any time like at night or when you are at work. You can set the timer and go anywhere.
  • It is the fastest and the best option for convenience.

Cons of using a full bread machine

  • The process is going to take time to complete so you cannot use the machine for doing anything else.
  • It is only capable of baking one loaf at a single time.
  • In general, you will only be given "bread forms," as your bread loaf cannot be made into any other shape.
  • They are built mainly for baking bread and thus are not generally flexible as a machine.

KitchenAid Stand mixer vs. Bread Machine

If you are going to prepare bread using a KitchenAid stand mixer or if you are thinking of buying a KitchenAid stand mixer then making bread might require more effort however it is a very versatile machine that can help you with many other things.

You can also make many different types of loaves at the same time and it can also help you a lot in other kitchen-related stuff too.

The bread machine is very good at making bread. Two types are explained above. If you want to make high-quality bread on its own. You won’t be required to do anything here. Just set the timer, place the ingredients, and walk away. However, it can only prepare one loaf at a time and it can only prepare bread which means it cannot do anything else.

Click here to buy the best KitchenAid stand mixer

Click here to buy the Best Bread machine


The decision here is very subjective as it depends on you. If you want a machine that helps you to prepare dough as well as help you with other things inside the kitchen then you can rely on the KitchenAid stand mixer but you will have to do many things for praying bread.

If you want a machine that can prepare the bread properly without any efforts needed from your side then a bread machine is the best option for you. It will do everything on its own and you are not required to monitor the process.

I hope this article was helpful and informative.


Similar Posts